Debate in XI Science 9 pt.2

Round 1 "The reality show brings more harm".

1. Opening Government
Agree that the reality show brings more harm because if we or teenagers watch it we can forget our time and didn't do homework or task.
2. Opening Opposition
Disagree because the reality show more entertain than another show like american got talent its very interesting and we can show our talent.
3. Opening Government
It's have less moral value and some of them doesn't have moral value.
4. Opening Opposition
bring us benefit like "katakan putus" we can know how to break up with boyfriend with the best way and "family 100" it can make family closer and can test our general knowledge.
5. Closing Government
Refutation the opinion from Opening Opposition 2 because they think that show can make children imitate it if they watch the show.
6. Closing Opposition
Reality show interesting to watch and the rating is good and about the children it's a parent task to keep their child watch good show.
7. Closing Government
Interrupt the opinion from Closing Opposition about rating because it's not just the rating but we should consider about the content.
8. Closing Opposition
It's not real story just a setting so just enjoy and don't rate it seriously.

winner : Closing Government
because I have same opinion with closing government that we should consider the content not just the rating.


Round 2 "TH would not use national examination for graduation standard"

1.Opening Government
Agree that national examination not use for graduation standard because education not just about the knowledge and if we not all of student can past them.
2.Opening Opposition
Disagree because the education system in Indonesia already apply the new curriculum (character) in 2013 so at these year until next few year national examination still use to be the standard.
3.Opening Government
National examination can make student depressed and give negative impact for student.
4. Opening Opposition
Depressed can cause they didn't prepare it for the long time and they study night or the day before the exam so it can make their depressed and it's true about there is another consideration like character and moral but we also need the knowledge score so we still need national examination and this year also we consider the character and moral but if the knowledge score is too low of course we can graduated the student.
5. Closing Government
National examination it's not the best way because there are many student who have another talent not just the academic like art, sport, entrepreneur, and other so I thing it is unfair for a part of students.
6. Closing Opposition
they can learn and expand their talent in University and the university also think and use the national exam for they knowledge score so although they have talent in art, sport, and other they general knowledge and their basic math are needed and used.
7. Closing Government
But because of that the student who can't or weak in academic will do every thing so they can past it even there is a bad things like cheating or maybe because they really depressed they do suicide so we should think about the psychic and moral of student.
8. Closing Opposition
Maybe right if we should consider about character, talent, psychic of the children but education system in this country not ready to apply it overall. maybe in the next year we will apply it overall from primary to  high school but for this year we still use it.

winner : Opening Government
because there are another consideration about the graduation standard but I also agree with the opposition that we still need national examination .